Back to all questions

What is the Difference Between Single and Multi-CDN?

Edward Tsinovoi
Multi-CDN Strategy
May 5, 2024

Think of your website as a retail chain that wants to deliver products (content) to customers (users) globally. A single CDN is like a retail chain with a number of stores (servers) spread across various regions. When a customer places an order, the nearest store delivers the product, which speeds up the delivery process compared to shipping from a distant warehouse. However, all these stores belong to one chain and might have limitations in certain areas.

A Multi-CDN strategy, in contrast, is like having several different retail chains (CDNs) with their own stores in various regions around the world. When a customer in Europe places an order, the nearest and most efficient store from any of these chains fulfills their order. This not only potentially reduces the delivery time but also provides redundancy and might improve availability during high demand or when one chain's store faces issues.

How a Single CDN Works

A Single CDN network offers a straightforward solution, especially for smaller websites with a limited budget. Setting up and managing a single network is a breeze, and the initial investment is typically lower compared to a Multi-CDN setup. 

However, there's a trade-off for this simplicity. Here's what you need to consider:

  • All your eggs are in one basket. If the CDN experiences technical difficulties or outages, your entire content delivery can grind to a halt, frustrating your users and potentially hurting your business.
  • A CDN's performance also depends on its distribution of servers globally and the current load on those servers. This means there can be situations where certain locations or times experience slower speeds even with a CDN, regardless of their proximity to central servers.

How a Multi-CDN Setup Works

A Multi-CDN approach distributes your content across multiple networks (CDNs) of geographically dispersed servers, offering several advantages:

  • Users worldwide can experience faster loading times thanks to content being served from CDNs most suited to their location and time. So, if one CDN performs better in Europe at a certain time, a Multi-CDN setup will use this data to ensure that specific CDN is utilized when serving content at that specific time and location. 
  • Redundancy is key. If one CDN encounters issues, the others can step up and continue delivering your content seamlessly. This ensures a more robust and reliable performance for your website.

A Multi-CDN network is particularly key for sectors like eCommerce, media, and gaming, where you’d want to make the experience as smooth as possible!

Where the Main Variability Lies

With a Multi-CDN solution, you're not tied down to the performance metrics or the geographic coverage of a single provider. Instead, you can tailor your content delivery strategy based on the strengths and weaknesses of multiple CDNs.

This allows for dynamic content routing, where requests are automatically directed to the best-performing CDN in real-time, further optimizing the user experience.

Cost considerations become a bit more complex. While a Multi-CDN providers setup might initially seem more expensive due to the involvement of multiple providers, the benefits of improved performance, reliability, and the potential for negotiating better rates due to competition among CDN providers can offset the higher costs. 

Moreover, the cost is an investment in providing a superior user experience and maintaining high availability, which is critical for retaining users and ensuring customer satisfaction in the long run.

Why A Multi-CDN Strategy is the Better Option Overall

Here’s a simple explanation of why Multi-CDNs are plainly better to go for, regardless of your business size and network traffic control strategy:

Feature Single CDN Multi-CDN
Complexity Simple, good for small businesses. Complex, but offers better performance and reliability.
Coverage Limited to CDN distribution; may slow distant deliveries. Global; uses multiple CDN distributions to speed up deliveries worldwide.
Cost Lower initial, with less room for negotiation. Higher initial, but with potential for optimization leading to lower costs the more the traffic.
Reliability Risk of outages affecting all content. High, with redundancy ensuring continuity.
Performance Adequate; can cause delays based on time frames. Excellent globally, optimizing user experience.
Flexibility Constrained by a single provider. High; easily adjusts to needs and performance.
User Experience Potentially compromised by distance or outages. Consistently optimized, enhancing satisfaction.